Insight

Hiring a Product Manager in Australia: the story a CV won't tell you

Published
6 October 2026
Author
Mike Clements
Category
Hiring
Reading time
6 min read

I studied English and American Literature at university, and for a while I wrote all the time. Recruitment has a way of turning that into emails and the occasional LinkedIn post, so it's been a while since I put the proverbial pen to paper on anything longer. This is me having a go.

It turns out the two jobs have more in common than I expected. Much of my day is spent explaining people and companies to each other, which is really a form of storytelling. When I call a candidate about a role, I tell them the company's story: where it's been, what it's trying to build, and why this hire matters now. When I put that candidate in front of a hiring manager, I'm telling the story the other way, explaining who this person is, what they've built and why they'd make sense in that team. If either story is thin, the process usually falls apart

Why the Product Manager title tells you so little

Take four Senior Product Managers in Sydney, each with seven years' experience and earning roughly the same. One has spent five years building 0 to 1 product in a 40-person SaaS business. One has run a billion-dollar consumer platform. One has spent a career inside a bank, working through regulation, risk and around 400 stakeholders. The fourth has the title but has mostly been running ceremonies and maintaining a backlog. On alist of applicants on an ATS they look almost identical. Each of them has a completely different story, and put in the same role they'd get four very different results.


The Product Manager job description problem

A job description is the first draft of the company's story, and it's often the weakest one. Senior Product Manager, 8+ years, B2B SaaS, enterprise, AI, data, technical, commercial, customer obsessed, strategic, strong leadership, comfortable with ambiguity. My first question is what problem the business is trying to solve. My second is whether this person exists. A lot of Product Manager job descriptions end up as a laundry list of everything anyone in the company has ever wanted from the role.

Reading Product Manager CVs in the age of AI

A CV used to be a rough first draft of someone's story. Now, with AI, it's increasingly a polished draft written in somebody else's voice, full of strategic, outcome-focused, customer-centric language. I've read enough Product CVs to last me several lifetimes, so I pay more attention to the conversation that follows. Ask someone about a product decision they got wrong, or something they chose not to build, and the corporate language disappears pretty quickly. The people who've actually made decisions have real stories to tell.

Five questions to answer before hiring a Product Manager

These are the questions that tell me what story I'll be telling candidates, and whether it's one a good Product Manager will want to hear.


  • What problem is this person being hired to solve? I mean the actual problem, which is usually different from the list of responsibilities.
  • What decisions will they own? "Owns the product" can mean almost anything.
  • How does your product organisation work? A PM in a trio with Design and Engineering and a PM wedged between heaps of stakeholders are doing two very different jobs.
  • Why would a good Product Manager leave their current role for this one? You're asking someone who already has a job to change their life, and they'll want a reason.
  • What are you prepared to compromise on? If the answer is nothing, it's going to be a tricky search.


Recruiting Product and Design from both sides

I run Liminal with Morgan Fletcher. We worked together at Sustain before leaving earlier this year to start our own Product and Design recruitment business in Sydney, built around the things we'd learned mattered most: specialist focus, shortlists that are actually short, and really knowing the people we put forward. I look after Product Management, Service Design and Research. Morgan recruits Product Designers, UI, Design Engineers and Design Systems people. Product Managers and Product Designers spend their working lives in the same trio, so between us we usually hear both halves of a team's story.

The story behind a Product Manager's CV

I'll allow myself one English Lit reference. Ernest Hemingway - excellent writer and enthusiastic if average boxer - reckoned the best stories keep most of themselves under the surface. Product Managers are much the same, with the CV is the bit above the water. Most of my job is finding that part of the story and telling it honestly to a hiring manager who has 300 applications and not much time to read them.

So I'll finish with a question for the Product Managers reading this. What's the best part of your story that never makes it onto your CV?

Let’s talk about what’s next…